The 777 Point Collapse
By Tommy Leung on September 29th, 2008 in Economics, News, Public Policy
The House defeated the $700 billion bailout plan today and the Dow Jones responded by dropping 777 points–777.68 to be exact. This was the largest single day drop ever. Analyst and politicians may start blaming the people for being non-supportive of this bill but, the market had to fall. It was up or held steady because of speculation that a bailout was coming and due to the naked short selling bans. The market is now merely doing what it is supposed to do: find equilibrium.
TV pundits and Washington elites will try and convince us that we need to do something now more than ever. We should continue to do nothing to bailout Wall Street. Any bailout will only compound the problem and cause more economic problems. We are in the worse crisis since the Great Depression and if government doesn’t keep its hands off, the problem is going to get much worse.
The idea that we need to ensure prices do not fall is a ridiculous notion. By propping up home prices, gas and food prices will go up as well and no one wants that. Housing prices cannot stay at their current levels. In most of the country, home prices have already fallen through the floor from their highs. There should still be more to go. In big cities like New York, real estate prices have held pretty well. It can’t and won’t last.
It was due to the government passing legislation that forced banks to lend money to anyone and everyone so that everyone could “own” a home that caused this crisis. If you cannot afford a home, you should not be buying one. Using “creative” financing is not a good solution. I don’t like to point a finger at any particular party but, in this case, it was the Democrats who pushed through the Community Reinvestment Act. It was originally signed by Carter in 1977 but, not well enforced and amended until 1995. Essentially, it was President Clinton who presided over the increase for mortgage access in inner cities and distressed rural communities.
This act also promoted the use of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac as a means to unload these mortgages due to their risky nature. Fannie and Freddie were GSEs–government sponsored enterprises–and now they are fully government owned. The two GSEs would repackage the mortgages as securities and sell them on the open market. Because Fannie and Freddie were government backed, their mortgage securities were given high ratings even though they clearly did not deserve it.
The point is, the government caused this horrible financial mess we are in. If left to free market devices, the amount of bad mortgages would have never risen to such levels. So when politicians–especially Democrats–try to blame this crisis on the lack of regulation, they are lying through their teeth or just plainly do not understand economics. Either of which is not a positive for holding public office.
The exponential rise of real estate prices is directly attributed to the massive amount of buyers that flooded into the real estate market due to government demanding everyone own a home and bid prices up higher and higher. Now because everyone’s houses went up in value, some decided it a good idea to refinance and borrow against their home so that they could take that vacation, buy that new car, or whatever. It was fun for several years until people started missing payments and foreclosures started taking place.
Housing prices started to collapse and now millions of Americans have upside down mortgages with negative equity in their homes. The party had ended and here comes the hang over.
Government bailouts and interference of market forces is the equivalent of drinking more and more alcohol in order to delay the hang over. It is logically not a good idea. You need to allow the alcohol to leave the body or in this case, allow the bad debt to leave the market. In fancy-pants talk, we need to liquidate the bad debt. It won’t be painless–hang overs aren’t painless but, they are necessary.
The economy is not in good shape and if we can keep the government from trying to “fix” things, it will start to improve a lot sooner. However, if we allow the government to intervene like it did during the 1930′s, the 16 year Great Depression is going to look like a walk in the park. We do not need government works projects or any other absurd creation of Hoover or Roosevelt.
While it is difficult to do nothing while people are suffering–you and me included, one must remember the ideas of economist Frederic Bastiat. We need to take into account the opportunity costs that we do not see. It may look like a good thing if government provides jobs because in the short run unemployment would be kept in check but, new and more efficient jobs and markets will not get the capital they need because government had directed capital elsewhere. That is exactly how a short painful recession can turn into a long painful depression.
The other danger of government intervention is that the only way government is going to be able to pay for the bailouts and works projects is to increase the national debt by borrowing or by printing more dollars. Both choices are incredibly bad. The current economic crisis won’t kill us, hyperinflation will. Having a lot of dollars is meaningless if they can’t buy anything. The Federal Reserve has already increased the money supply by 8% in the last week to try and “smooth” the gears of the financial system–it won’t work. It is only going to devalue the dollars we currently have.
It was a great victory for the American people today that this bailout of the rich and well connected was defeated. We cannot privatize profits and socialize losses. It is unlikely that Paulson, Bernanke, Bush, and co. is going to let it go. They will try to push some sort of bailout through as best as they can. The Senate will vote on the bill later in the week. This bill does nothing to benefit the people. We need to tell our Senators that we do not support the bill and demand that they vote against it.
Any Senator who votes for this bill should not expect to be re-elected. This is a grand robbery of the American people and I’m glad we didn’t stand for it. The massive public outrage over this bailout bill played a great role in its defeat in the House. Today was a victory for the people. May we continue the fight.
For more insights into the economic crisis and its inner workings, check out LewRockwell.com and The Mises Institute.





